Short version: When finance outgrows the owner at night, you can hire full-time, outsource to a firm, or go fractional. Senior finance work is mostly periodic, which is why a full-time hire is often more capacity than the work needs. Name the job (bookkeeper, controller, or CFO), then match the form: constant work points to a hire, periodic senior work to fractional, clean records to a firm.
At some point the finance function outgrows the owner doing it at night and the bookkeeper keeping the records. The work that's missing, the forecasting, the margin analysis, the reporting someone relies on, the strategic decisions, needs a senior person. The question is what form that person takes: a full-time hire, an outsourced firm, or a fractional executive. Pick wrong and you either overpay for capacity you don't use or underbuy and stay stuck.
Here's how to think about it, including the honest case for each.
Before deciding the form, get clear on the role, because people conflate three different jobs.
A bookkeeper records transactions and reconciles. A controller owns the close, makes the books trustworthy and current, and builds the reporting. A CFO uses trustworthy books to forecast, price, fund growth, and decide. Most owners who feel the pain need the controller or CFO layer, and they often need less of it than they think, because the work is periodic. The close happens monthly. The forecast updates weekly. The big decisions come a few times a year. Very little of senior finance work actually requires forty hours a week.
That last fact is what makes the form decision interesting.
The case for it: a full-time controller or CFO is embedded, available every day, and fully inside your business. For a company large or complex enough to generate a true full-time load, strong cash needs, lots of entities, heavy compliance, a finance team to manage, it's the right answer and nothing else substitutes.
The cost: a competent controller runs well into six figures all-in; a CFO considerably more, $200,000 to $400,000 once you count salary, bonus, and benefits. And you're buying forty hours whether the work fills them or not. For most businesses under roughly $20 million in revenue, a full-time senior finance hire is both more than the budget allows and more capacity than the work requires. You end up with an expensive person doing work below their level to fill the week.
The case for it: an outsourced accounting firm gives you a team, continuity, and a price often lower than a hire. Good for getting reliable books and a clean close without managing the people yourself.
The limit: most outsourced firms are strong on the bookkeeping-to-controller range and thin on the CFO layer. You get accurate records and a close, which is real value, but the strategic work, the forecasting tied to your decisions, the pricing analysis, the sitting-across-the-table-from-a-lender, is often not what they do, or it's a senior person spread across forty clients who can give yours an hour. If what you need is clean books, this can be ideal. If what you need is a financial thought partner, it frequently isn't.
The case for it: a fractional controller or CFO gives you a senior person at the level you need, for the days a month the work actually takes, at a fraction of a full-time cost. It fits the reality that senior finance work is periodic. You get the forecasting, the margin work, the reporting, the decision support, scaled to your size, and you can dial it up around a raise, a sale, or a crisis, and back down when things are steady.
The honest limit: a fractional person is not there every day, so it's the wrong fit if you genuinely need daily hands-on finance presence or a full-time team lead. It works best when the need is senior judgment applied periodically, which is the common case, and less well when the need is constant coverage, which is the rarer one.
Three questions sort most situations:
It's rarely one choice forever. A common and sensible path: keep a bookkeeper for the daily records, add a fractional controller or CFO for the close, reporting, and decisions, and convert to a full-time hire only when the business is large enough to keep that person genuinely busy. The fractional stage isn't a compromise on the way to the real thing. For most businesses it is the right thing, often for years.
The two-minute version: write down the specific finance work that isn't getting done, and estimate how many hours a month it actually takes. If it's a few days, not a few weeks, you have your answer, and it isn't a full-time hire.
Figuring out exactly what the finance function needs, and in what form, is itself a conversation worth having before you spend on any of the three. Tell me what's not getting done and what decision is in front of you, and I'll tell you honestly which of these fits, even if the answer is that you don't need me yet.
Tell me the specific work that isn't getting done and the decision in front of you, and I'll tell you honestly which of the three fits, even if the answer is that you don't need me yet.
If the finance work is constant and heavy enough to genuinely fill a full-time role, hire. For most businesses under roughly $20 million in revenue, senior finance work is periodic, so a fractional CFO gives you the right level of help for the days a month it actually takes, at a fraction of the cost.
Outsourced firms are strong on bookkeeping-to-controller work: clean books and a reliable close. Many are thin on the CFO layer (forecasting, pricing, strategy, sitting across from a lender). If you need records, a firm fits; if you need decisions, you need CFO-level help.
Roughly $200,000 to $400,000 all-in once you count salary, bonus, and benefits, and you're buying forty hours whether the work fills them or not. For most small and midsize businesses that's more than the budget allows and more capacity than the work requires.
Keep a bookkeeper for daily records, add a fractional controller or CFO for the close, reporting, and decisions, and convert to a full-time hire only when the business is large enough to keep that person genuinely busy. The fractional stage is often the right answer for years.
General guidance for business owners, not accounting, tax, legal, or investment advice. Your situation may differ; confirm specifics with your own professionals. Engagements are contracted through Northstar Rose, LLC.
Plain-English guides on running the finances of a small business. One email per guide. Unsubscribe in a click.